Chillicothe man creates custom-made lures



Paul Clay checks newly molded lead jigs he makes in his Chillicothe, Ill., workshop on April 9, 2008. Painted jigs in the foreground cool after being baked in an oven. Clay is one of the few Peoria-area anglers who still sell their own custom-made fishing Jeff Lampe, The Associated Press

By Jeff Lampe

CHILLICOTHE, Ill. – Paul Clay is one of the few Peoria-area anglers who still sell their own custom-made fishing lures. His first creation was a piece of plastic worm with rubber bands tied here and there.

“We called it the Rockbuster because rock bass used to really like it,” Clay said.

The heyday of the Rockbuster came and went nearly 40 years ago while Clay was growing up in Princeville. But Clay, now 48 and living in a restored farmhouse northwest of Chillicothe, still enjoys creating fishing lures.

For the past decade he’s kept busy making jigs, spinnerbaits and more recently, chatterbaits for bass anglers. Most days when Clay returns home from work at the Mitsubishi Motors plant in Normal, Ill., he heads to his shed. There he turns chunks of scrap lead into fishing jigs, using a variety of custom molds.

After a few hours of molding, Clay moves inside to a bedroom where he powder paints jigs, adds plastic skirts and tinkers with his creations. Always he looks for improvements, relying largely on input from co-workers or tournament anglers. The irony is he’s too busy modifying his baits to actually use them much.

Get The Daily Illini in your inbox!

  • Catch the latest on University of Illinois news, sports, and more. Delivered every weekday.
  • Stay up to date on all things Illini sports. Delivered every Monday.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Thank you for subscribing!

“I fish, but not as much as I used to,” Clay said. “I don’t have time.”

Among his latest improvements is upgrading hooks. He also top coats jigs with epoxy paint to help reduce chipping.

Clay calls his latest creation the Mad Willow. It’s basically a chatterbait with a willow-leaf spinnerbait blade dangling under the hook.

“It’s the coolest bait to watch in the water because the blade doesn’t spin, it flutters,” Clay said.

His spinnerbaits are more popular, though any sales are by word of mouth. Clay has never advertised his Dine-a-mite Bait company. Even so, a handful of tournament bass anglers regularly call Clay with orders for specific combinations of colors, blades, paint patterns and hook sizes.

A typical call might be from an angler wanting a buzzbait that spins counterclockwise instead of clockwise. Or a spinnerbait with a wild pink, hatchet-shaped blade.

“I can throw together about anything you want,” said Clay, who takes orders via e-mail at [email protected] or at (309) 251-6611.

And there’s definitely a market for his services. While the racks of tackle shops are already packed with what might appear to be every color or shape of lure imaginable, there’s always someone who can’t find what they want.

Locating custom-made lures to fill that niche is not easy, even though the Internet is filled with helpful Web sites like That’s not really a huge surprise. What would you rather do, fish or spend a day being splattered with hot lead while molding jigs?

“I just like the making part,” Clay said, shaking off another lead splatter. “It’s not for the money, for sure.”

That’s true because another appeal of Clay’s creations is his “Wal-Mart pricing”: Arky-head or football-head bass jigs with rattles are $2.50, buzzbaits cost $2.50, chatterbaits $3, Mad Willow chatterbaits $4, bass spinnerbaits $4, crappie spinners $2.5 and five crappie jigs sell for $1.

At those prices, Clay will never be enticed to retire early from Mitsubishi. But he will entice anglers to keep using his lures. Really, that’s what he’s after.

“When guys fish a tournament and call me to say they caught fish with my lures, it’s cool. It makes me feel good,” Clay said. “It’s fun to have people be successful with things you make.”